An update on two Downtown shelters

320 Pearl

The Safe Haven shelter at 320 Pearl next to Peck Slip School was opened during the stretch of brutal weather we had this winter, and will stay open — the city defended its placement by filing a new Fair Share statement. The city’s Fair Share policy is designed to ensure that certain city facilities — such as jails, homeless shelters and sanitation garages — are distributed equitably across all neighborhoods citywide.

The second shelter at 41-43 Beekman is also on track, with an anticipated late 2027 opening. That will be a long-term shelter for 170 single men in a five-story residential building between William and Gold. The city has been prepping for that since 2023.

41-43 Beekman

The city’s Department of Homeless Service’s press office clarified that when the community group Peckslip Advocates for School Safety challenged the agency’s siting process in court, the judge ruled that the approval process was flawed — that the city failed to demonstrate that it fully considered all potential negative effects of the shelter. The city answered that with the new Fair Share statement in early February and was then able to proceed, it seems, without the judge reviewing the new statement.

“We have remained in close contact with this community and local elected officials, taking steps to address their concerns ahead of opening,” a spokesman for DHS said. “As always, we will maintain these lines of communication, work to address additional concerns as they arise, and collaborate with the community to support our vulnerable neighbors as they come inside and begin their journey to stability.”

The Pearl Street Safe Haven is operated by Breaking Ground and offers 106 beds for both older men and women and the medically frail. The agency said the majority of people placed there are already living unsheltered in the area.

Safe Haven shelters are low barrier shelters, meaning there are fewer rules for residents and they are not required to be sober or drug-free. They are designed to get the most intransigent homeless off the streets. Breaking Ground will provide around-the-clock, on-site security, the DHS said. Also, approximately 60 security cameras will be installed throughout the building. These cameras allow security officers to continually monitor compliance with house regulations and “good neighbor” policies both in and around the facility.

Breaking Ground will also:

  • install privacy screening material on all interior windows facing the adjacent school
  • limit the ability to open all Safe Haven windows to 4 inches
  • install a canopy over the outdoor interior courtyard that obstructs the view from above

“Safe Havens provide specialized overnight beds as well as both physical and program characteristics that are specifically designed to address these individuals’ unique needs, including, for example, featuring smaller physical settings and as more hands-on and intimate case management,” DHS said. “Safe Havens coordinate closely with outreach teams, who refer individuals experiencing unsheltered homelessness directly for placement.”

[I will note that the DHS asked me to avoid revealing the full addresses, since city shelter locations are on a protected list, but I don’t really see how that applies here since 1) the sites were discussed at public meetings and 2) everyone already knows the buildings we are talking about.]

 

7 Comments

  1. DHS request is interesting and I appreciate you noting that they made that request.

    They are just functionaries and don’t make the rules but it’s telling how they advance the propaganda of their bosses, be it Adams or Mamdani.

    I think it’s very interesting that 320 Pearl St. is essentially the Adams plan yet Mamdani / DHS never mentions it, suggesting that it’s quite useful to BLAME the former Mayor for this and that but not to CREDIT him for things they believe he was correct about.

    Re: Breaking Ground, look up the executive pay figures of this and other “non-profit” homeless services providers– including over the last 5 or 6 years via Pro Publica Charity NonProfit Explorer. It’s pretty eye-popping.

    • Agree. If it’s true that Mamdani and Julie Menin are bring back year round outdoor dining ( some cafés and restaurants never stopped) they might have to consult with Eric Adam’s to deal with the rat problem again!

  2. This should be part of Hochul’s newfound pitch to get people back from Florida as she runs out of other peoples money to spend- well put a homeless/illegal immigrant shelter next to your kids school! What an incredibly stupid idea. This city never fails to impress me

  3. If I had a child at Peck Slip School, I would be furious beyond belief. To see the city prioritizing the homeless over children’s safety at that school is an utter embarrassment. In fact, everyone attached to this decsion should be embarassed.

  4. This is idiotic at best a homeless shelter should never be next to an elementary school. This was previously voted down and I could see the emergency usage, but that’s in the past the mayor is going beyond his authority yet again. New York does not need a demigo. It’s ironic he acts just like trump but from a mirror image on the left side of the aisle. I hope to god that he’s a one term mayor.

  5. No outrage or protest. No TV interview from parents or community? How can you allow this to happen after Judege ruling!

Comment: