November 2, 2026 Community News, Real Estate, Restaurant/Bar News, Shopping
THE SENEGALESE VENDORS OF CANAL STREET
The Times has another feature on Canal Street, this time on the Senegalese vendors, who, they said, “have adapted with a relentless sidewalk hustle, sustaining their families through street vending.” “Even if I have to sell water and make 50 cents out of every bag that I sell, I will do it,” Abdoul Azez Kasse told the Times. “I will do it because I believe that here, work is worship.” With the weeks and resources they spent on that story, I wish they delved into the real power structure in that market…
ANOTHER CONVERSION FOR FIDI?
The Commercial Observer has a story saying that plans have been filed with DOB for a 99-unit rental at 160 Pearl, between Pine and Wall. The Full Shilling, which opened there in 1999, is on the ground floor. The bar inside is 100 years old and came from a bar in Belfast.
BILLIONAIRE BUYS IN 111 MURRAY
The Wall Street Journal reports that Fashion Nova CEO Richard Saghian bought a $31 million penthouse at 111 Murray. The apartment is five-bedrooms, 7,700 square feet, with a 2000-square-foot great room. He also has a $126 million megamansion in Bel-Air.
THE ROW AND ITS $1 BILLION LABEL
If you can get past the paywall, (I can’t) The Observer has a story on The Row, the company that has taken the former Issey Miyake space on Hudson. Trying to get more info… Miyake left that space after 24 years.
Some puzzling and inconsistent aspects about the NYT article on street vendors from Senegal.
For example, the article made little mention of asylum situations, instead indicating the economic focus and hope to attain the “American Dream”
Also the article mentions generically that “they” flew from Senegal to Mexico and then made the journey from Mexico to the U.S border. The article does not mention why “they” did not fly directly to the US (and presumably request asylum?)
The article did not indicate if the reporter conducted all interviews directly and what language or if an interpreter was used?
likely since they can’t obtain visas to come to the US via the regular channels. Only way for them to do so is to cross the border illegally and file for asylum with CBP.
Does the article mention how these entrepreneurs are part of organized crime networks, that counterfeiting is one of the main sources of income for organized crime, and that it even funds terrorism? Does it mention the effects on the neighborhood, on businesses and those living in the area?
these criminals because that is exactly what they are are storing their counterfeit goods in storage places all over the city. Near the tunnel is one place. Vote accordingly
Yes they use the Manhattan Mini-Storage at 78 Walker also. That seems a natural target for enforcement then.
Marcus,
What’s your evidence for these claims?
“Does the article mention how these entrepreneurs are part of organized crime networks, that counterfeiting is one of the main sources of income for organized crime, and that it even funds terrorism”?
It’s a federal crime to sell counterfeit goods:
https://www.thefederalcriminalattorneys.com/trafficking-counterfeit-goods
Clearly it’s a network, as these sellers do not manufacture the goods. So there are illegal producers, illegal importers, etc., i.e. an organized crime network.
Info on counterfeiting and organized crime:
https://unicri.org/sites/default/files/2019-11/Report%20on%20the%20Counterfeiting%20and%20Organized%20Crime.pdf
Info on counterfeiting links:
“The impact of counterfeit and pirated goods is broader than just unfair competition. Law
enforcement officials have uncovered intricate links between the sale of counterfeit goods and
transnational organized crime. A study by the Better Business Bureau notes that the financial
operations supporting counterfeit goods typically require central coordination, making these
activities attractive for organized crime, with groups such as the Mafia and the Japanese Yakuza
heavily involved.33 Criminal organizations use coerced and child labor to manufacture and sell
counterfeit goods. In some cases, the proceeds from counterfeit sales may be supporting terrorism
and dictatorships throughout the world.”
https://www.dhs.gov/sites/default/files/publications/20_0124_plcy_counterfeit-pirated-goods-report_01.pdf
Much more info available online of course.
The vendors are expanding their footprint and have taken over areas on Broadway. This is already significantly changiing the character of Soho.
very disturbing for store owners and people who live in the area. Blame the voters that voted in this Mayor. They also sell drugs on canal street beside bags. Its disgusting
We have now had several mayors in a row who clearly don’t care about this problem, or even implicitly support the presence of the sellers, or at any rate are afraid to criticize or enforce for fear of being labeled “anti-immigrant” or whatever.
Even the affected galleries seem afraid to report it or do anything about it, or even more odd, refer to the sellers as ““excellent neighbors and great colleagues on the block” and describe the counterfeit bazaar as “beloved and long-standing part of the neighborhood ecosystem and character”. Are they kidding? Who in the neighborhood considers this situation “beloved” or essential to Tribeca’s “character”? Apparently it’s only “beloved” to tourists who do not care about its effects on the neighborhood (or links to organized crime, etc.).
Source: https://hyperallergic.com/tribeca-galleries-discuss-reporting-street-vendors-drawing-criticism/
But of course you can be pro-immigration and still be against this counterfeit bazaar. Also you can be against ICE’s brutal tactics and still want fair and proper enforcement of the laws and regulations, including those about allowed areas for vending, laws against counterfeiting, and all the related issues (littering, obstructing sidewalks, harassing pedestrians, public urination, etc.).
Cynics might suggest someone in authority is profiting from this situation, which would explain lack of will to do anything about it. I don’t know if that is true though.
Well said, Marcus – completely agree. Convoluting immigration with illegal street vending is a distraction from the real issue. Enforcing existing laws shouldn’t be controversial.
Yes, they have been massively expanding both up and down Broadway from Canal, so it’s also changing the character of this part of Tribeca. Those deeper into Tribeca may not notice it yet, but beware if we let this problem keep growing.
The blocks of Broadway between Canal and Lispenard, and Lispenard and Walker are already totally taken over, and recently it’s spreading to the next block down, between Walker and White. I used to like to visit the galleries on that stretch, but no more. I don’t want to deal with that chaos.
It’s also spreading further along Canal Street. Now they often occupy the block with the post office on it also. So they sell counterfeit junk – a federal felony offense – right in front of a federal building, with no enforcement or consequences.
A friend (former, New Yorker, who was forced to leave NYC due to cost of living) visited the city and asked me, after trying to walk through the areas of the counterfeit bazaar (and also witnessing people smoking on the subway, people regularly driving through red lights, and the sheer amount of litter around Canal Street, plus the overwhelming stench of pee around the post office, etc.) – “So I guess the law doesn’t mean anything here anymore then?”
Recently the sellers on Broadway have been congregated on the west side of Broadway, with few on the east side. I assume this is due to difference in precinct enforcement. West side is precinct #1, and I believe east side is #5. Why is #5 failing to enforce? Why isn’t there more coordinated effort between the 2 precincts? It’s bizarre and almost comical to see police cars on one side of the street, so that side is clear of sellers, while just across the street there are 100 sellers with no enforcement at all.
these criminals meet up at the Post office on Canal Street. This mayor is allowing much more to happen. Like the homeless encampments growing in our city. The Cops have their hands tied. They arrest and they are let out. We need law and order in NY. Vote accordingly. Its quality of like and safety issue. Not a Party issue
Marcus raises an important point, as do Lisa and Larry.
But this is 1000% ** organized crime **. If you are able, walk Canal Street between 8 and 9 am west of Broadway and you’ll see the merchandise dropoffs being made by men in mini-vans and station wagons, both on the sidestreets north of Canal and out by the Holland Tunnel.
All these sob story pieces about the poor Senegalese ignore– be it on purpose or ignorance– the manufacturers and distributors involved. How much for those counterfeit Apple AirPodMax?
I can empathize with Senegalese and other West African struggle also but let’s face reality too.
Julie (speaking Wolof on Walker Street)
The NYPD 1st and 5th precinct have scheduled community council meetings that the public can attend and ask questions. I can not attend but if you are concerned with the illegal vendors please attend, ask questions, and please report back here.
https://sohobroadway.org/nypd-community-council/
The 1st precinct: Monday, December 7th, 7 p.m. at New York Law School
The 5th precinct: Wednesday, November 18th at the Confucius Plaza Community Room (33 Bowery).
Unfortunately both those times are work times for me, so I cannot attend. Yes please if anyone does go please voice these concerns and report back.
I have spoken numerous times with the police in 1st precinct though, and always get a similar response: There is nothing more they can do. There is no will to enforce the law with significant penalties.
Arrests have no effect because the sellers are right back out the next day. Apparently they can often even get back their seized items. Sellers are clearly not concerned about the police. They are laughing while running away from the police.
Even the occasional “big” raids have no lasting effect. Within a day the sellers are back out with more future landfill to sell.
The change apparently has to come from elsewhere. Mayor’s office? District attorney? Who sets the terms here?
There has to be will to actually hold the sellers accountable, and to impose severe enough penalties that this ends. That enforcement can also go along with programs to shift these sellers into law-abiding jobs.
Also:
– It should be made illegal to buy counterfeit goods, as it is in many countries. Not sure if that must happen at federal level, or can happen at state or local level.
– The supply chain sources must be targeted more extensively: warehouses, importers, local storage facilities.
– The junk and the horrible carts have to be confiscated regularly, and not returned to the sellers.
(The carts have made things much worse in every way: they take up much more space, make it easier for the get-away, and locals risk getting run over when a crowd of sellers runs with their carts from the latest police arrival).
– All the associated quality of life and safety issues need to be enforced: public urination, littering, obstruction of public space and sidewalks (violation of ADA, among other things?), etc.
– Not to mention that they have pushed and threatened neighbors. Not acceptable.
There is a simple solution and you can make it a three strikes and you’re out rule if you do not want to do zero tolerance. The police need to arrest the vendors and if caught for the third time it is an automatic felony and mandatory jail time. If you are illegal, the city turns you over to ICE on the third arrest. This would clear up things immediately. It will never happen because no one in power really cares about the people who elect them and are more wedded to their ideology. Unless we change the people in power, this will never get solved.
When the IP/trademark holders sue the City of New York (Department of Transportation) as owner of the sidewalks (its “inalienable property”) for turning a blind eye to sales of counterfeit goods, using the same laws they formerly used to go after landlords of stores selling counterfeit goods, then maybe you will see change.
See OMEGA SA v. 375 CANAL, LLC, Dist. Court, SD New York 2013
Defendants may be contributorially liable for the direct infringement of others: (1) if the defendant “intentionally induces another to infringe a trademark,” or (2) if the defendant “continues to supply its service to one whom it knows or has reason to know is engaging in trademark infringement.” Tiffany (NJ) Inc. v. eBay, Inc., 600 F.3d 93, 106 (2d Cir. 2010) (quoting Inwood Labs, Inc. v. Ives Labs Inc., 456 U.S. 844, 854 (1982)). Plaintiffs do not allege that 375 Canal has intentionally induced infringement. Instead, they allege that 375 Canal has contributorially infringed by continuing to supply services to a known infringer. Courts have held that the doctrine of contributory liability applies with equal force to landlords.[1] E.g., Hard Rock Café Licensing Corp. v. Concession Servs., Inc., 955 F.2d 1143, 1149 (7th Cir. 1992) (owner/operator of a flea market whose vendors were alleged to have sold infringing t-shirts); Ralph Lauren Corp. v. Chinatown Gift Shop, 855 F. Supp. 648, 650 (S.D.N.Y. 1994) (lessor of premises to retailers selling counterfeit goods in New York City’s Chinatown area). Defendant 375 Canal does not object to the applicability of this theory of landlord liability and so the Court assumes that landlords can be contributorially liable.
[…]
With regard to Plaintiffs’ theory of contributory liability, that 375 Canal “continues to supply its [premises] to one whom it knows or has reason to know is engaging in trademark infringement,” the Court concludes that Plaintiffs have pled facts sufficient to plausibly establish that 375 Canal knew or at least had reason to know that it was renting its premises to be used to sell counterfeit goods.
[…]
“The owner of real property, knowingly leasing or giving possession of the same to be used or occupied, wholly or partly, for any unlawful . . . business, or knowingly permitting the same to be so used, is liable [jointly and] severally . . . for any damage resulting from such unlawful use, occupancy, trade, manufacture or business.” N.Y. Real Prop. L. § 231(2). Section 231(2) is applicable to premises used for the sale and storage of counterfeit goods. See 1165 Broadway Corp. v. Dayana of N.Y. Sportswear, Inc., 633 N.Y.S.2d 724, 726 (1995) (construing the virtually identical language in section 231(1) prohibiting use of the premises for any “illegal trade, manufacture or other business”); Winter, McKinney’s Practice Commentary, Real Property § 231 (2006). While the statute requires that the lessor know of the unlawful activity, Alonso v. Branchinelli, 277 A.D.2d 408, 409 (N.Y. App. Div. 2d Dep’t 2000), Plaintiffs have pled sufficient facts to raise a plausible inference that 375 Canal did know. 375 Canal denies knowing, but at the pleading stage, the simple denial is insufficient to support the motion to dismiss. Accordingly, with respect to this claim as well, Defendant’s motion to dismiss is denied.
Note that it need not be the trademark owners who sue NYC. You can sue if there are vendors near your building.
N.Y. Real Prop. L. § 231(6) states:
Any owner or tenant, including a tenant of one or more rooms of an apartment house, tenement house or multiple dwelling of any premises within two hundred feet of the demised real property, may commence an action or proceeding in supreme court to enjoin the continued unlawful trade, manufacture or other business in such premises.
This is organized crime – it requires Federal investigation and enforcement. Every one of us should report it to the local field office of the FBI (there is an online tip form where you can remain anonymous or leave your contact information). Also – if you have license plate numbers for the minivans and station wagons delivering the illicit goods, you need to provide it to the FBI. Let’s do something to solve this.
Can we please stop calling them “vendors”!!
A vendor runs a business that sells merchandise to other businesses. E.g. a plumbing supply vendor.
A peddler is someone who peddles goods on the street.
They were always called peddlers but then some guy (who has no peddlers on his block in the UES) started the Street Vendors Project about 25 years ago to legitimize them.
It caught on and now they have risen to “vendors” even by the NY Times.
Let us control the dialogue. That is half the battle.
Call them what they are: “peddlers”: peddling smuggled, counterfeit goods and part of a transnational criminal organization.
There is widespread agreement that the illegal Canal vendors are destroying the quality of life for local residents because they block the sidewalks, soak up on street parking with their supply vehicles, attract rats by leaving half eaten food containers all over and use the street for a toilet.
When I ask the 1st Precinct cops why they don’t do anything they give me the same answer, “Our bosses told us not to touch those guys.”
In other words our elected local officials support the presence of the vendors. Our officials reflect the values of the voters, ourselves. Tribecans overwhelming support open borders and would rather be crucified than have someone call them “racist.”
The vendors will stay until we Tribecans change our attitude and vote differently.
UN report on counterfeiting and organized crime:
https://www.unodc.org/toc/en/crimes/counterfeit-goods.html
Blame those in charge, including our mayor.
Mamdani pledged support for NYC street vendors. Now they’re facing a crackdown.
https://gothamist.com/news/mamdani-pledged-support-for-nyc-street-vendors-now-theyre-facing-a-crackdown
(Crackdown? What crackdown?)